Review: U: The Comedy of Global Warming.
The play opens with text scrolling across a screen a la the Star Wars titles.
Which makes it strangely appropriate to share an anecdote (or it could just be an urban myth – who knows?) with you. During the filming of Star Wars Episode IV George Lucas supposedly derided Harrison Ford’s delivery of one his lines to which the actor allegedly replied, “You might be able to write this shit George but I can’t say it.”
Which is why I can’t find it in my heart to criticise any of the performances in U: The Comedy Of Global Warming. The three actors tasked with bringing the crudely drawn caricatures presented to them to life were locked into a collision course with the Death Star the moment they signed on the dotted line.
Now Star Wars isn’t a comedy by name or nature. Despite what some of us may think of the most recent cinema outings of the franchise. Unfortunately this play is supposed to be one and the word comedy in it’s title hangs like a millstone around its neck. Or should that be a noose.
That Ian Leung has researched the subject of global warming fully is evident. He shows great skill in succinctly explaining some quite complex ideas and concepts in a manner that is easy for an audience to process and understand. In isolated circumstances, i.e. outside of the play, these descriptions would be both entertaining and informative. Where it all falls down is in his insistence to then hang it all on such a weak skeleton.
The main dramatic premise (and there is a second which I’ll come to shortly) serves as a metaphor for the plays political aspirations and is scribbled in crayon three miles high. Oil rich Alberta (and presumably the Western world as a whole) using its fiscal and political power to screw poorer and weaker nations. Quite literally, in this case, fucking the little guy in the ass. In a clumsy manner at first that is slightly tasteless and I’m certain would stand up in court as attempted rape.
Both actors, Clinton Carew (as Albert A. Oil, just guess what his character represents) and Tim Hamaguchi (Tuvalan refugee, Tivo), show glimmers of their comic skills which unfortunately only serves to highlight the plays comic shortcomings. I am ashamed to say I didn’t so much as crack a smile except when the house-lights came up for dramatic effect at a couple of moments in the play and I felt it would be cruel not to at least pretend to be enjoying myself. Just for the sake of the performers egos.
The second dramatic conceit takes the form of a talk-show, Hotstove Planet, presented by Clinton Carew (enthusiastically portrayed by Garett Spelliscy). It intersperses the main storyline and introduces us to what is no doubt the most interesting aspect of the play. The documentary interviews from activists, scientists and politicians in Alberta who were filmed in order to provide a backdrop and some sorely needed gravitas to proceedings.
Their contributions lift what is on the whole a lifeless theatre going experience and without their inclusion I don’t think it would be unfair of any audience forced to sit through the rest of the show to then demand all or at least a portion of their money back.
If the ‘doom and gloom’ documentary market weren’t already flooded (excuse the pun) I would advise the plays director to bundle the interviews together and construct a narrative from them instead. I was only remotely interested in what was going on onstage when they were playing on the screens above and behind the cast and indeed found myself getting annoyed when the demands of the play meant that an interviewees comment was cut short or talked over in order to return to the ‘action’.
Perhaps I’m being unfair. Global warming in itself is not a funny subject so maybe there is a sense of irony in the title. I have a sneaking suspicion though that I’m wrong. This is supposed to be funny. This is supposed to have us rolling in the aisles. My advice to the writer if he wants the play to have a life beyond its short run at the U of A. Stick a couple of jokes in there. One would do to start.